Stadium: Art Keller Field Round: 1
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2022/10/01 18:00 | Elmhurst Bluejays v Carthage Red Men | W | 21-57 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2021/09/18 18:00 | Elmhurst Bluejays v Carthage Red Men | W | 17-34 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2019/10/05 18:00 | Elmhurst Bluejays v Carthage Red Men | W | 14-38 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2018/09/29 18:00 | Carthage Red Men v Elmhurst Bluejays | W | 63-7 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2023/09/23 18:00 | Washington Bears v Carthage Red Men | L | 38-7 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2023/09/16 18:00 | North Central Cardinals v Carthage Red Men | L | 70-0 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2023/09/02 18:00 | Carthage Red Men v Albion Britons | L | 20-41 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2022/11/12 19:00 | Carthage Red Men v Millikin Big Blue | L | 6-17 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2022/11/05 18:00 | Augustana College v Carthage Red Men | W | 30-37 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2022/10/29 18:00 | Carroll Pioneers v Carthage Red Men | L | 59-14 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2022/10/22 18:00 | Illinois Wesleyan Titans v Carthage Red Men | L | 55-0 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2022/10/15 18:00 | Carthage Red Men v Wheaton Thunder | L | 24-59 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2023/09/23 19:00 | Elmhurst Bluejays v North Central Cardinals | L | 6-59 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2023/09/16 23:00 | Augustana College v Elmhurst Bluejays | L | 74-6 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2023/09/02 18:00 | Elmhurst Bluejays v Adrian Bulldogs | W | 14-3 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2022/11/12 19:00 | Elmhurst Bluejays v Illinois Wesleyan Titans | L | 17-21 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2022/11/05 18:00 | North Park Vikings v Elmhurst Bluejays | L | 23-20 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2022/10/29 18:00 | Elmhurst Bluejays v Washington Bears | L | 6-49 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2022/10/22 18:00 | Millikin Big Blue v Elmhurst Bluejays | L | 13-0 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2022/10/15 23:00 | Elmhurst Bluejays v Carroll Pioneers | L | 28-31 |